While Pritzker said the measure would cut costs and improve returns for recipients, three dozen current employees and retirees, along with 18 local retirement plans, filed the lawsuit in February. Copyright 2023 Asset International, Inc. All Rights Reserved. We held in that case that the clause means precisely what it says: if something qualifies as a benefit of the enforceable contractual relationship resulting from membership in one of the States pension or retirement systems, it cannot be diminished or impaired (p. 14). I dont think many of us trust the government of Illinois to handle our money given their history, said Jim Kayes, president of the DeKalb Police Pension Fund board, which is among the plaintiffs. The move is intended to help improve the financial stability of the pension funds and ease pressure on local governments to raise taxes to fund those pensions. Illinois Public Pensions Database. In fact, the text cites multiple attempts to provide some alternate language to the constitutions blanket statement, which did not succeed: We note, moreover, that after the drafters of the 1970 Constitution initially approved the pension protection clause, a proposal was submitted to Delegate Green by the chairperson of the Illinois Public Employees Pension Laws Commission, an organization established by the General Assembly to, inter alia, offer recommendations regarding the impact of proposed pension legislation. Brian Granato Mike Pritchard, Sr. . (The other is New York.) Police and fire pension costs for DeKalb, Illinois, use up about 20% of general fund revenue, up from 10% in 2014, city manager Bill Nicklas said in an interview. A limit was also imposed on the amount of earnings used to calculate final average salary. 3) Increase final average salary. JB Pritzker himself, that those future accruals are guaranteed under the contracts clause of the United States Constitution, or by applying basic principles of justice and fairness, so that an amendment could never actually accomplish its purpose. Unfortunately, we know there is no political will, on the part of those currently in power. What the grassroots Illinoisians think about it is another question. Consolidation was also proposed in Pennsylvania in 2012 and 2018. In the task force report, the cost is estimated at $70 million to $95 million over five years, or $14 million to $19 million per year, but there is no supporting documentation for the estimate. In Illinois, there is a rich body of law concerning interference with pension rights and benefits. t 312.346.5700 f 312.896.2500, Springfield Office | Illinois Policy The state's pension consolidation task force reported doing so could earn the funds an extra $2.5 billion altogether over the next five years. The legislation impairs the exclusivity and rights of the local funds to manage their funds locally and impairs and diminishes their ability to vote and to have their vote count, Daniel Konicek, of Konicek & Dillon which is representing the police funds, said in an interview. Protected by Google ReCAPTCHA. Any increase in actual returns will be partly due to the consolidated funds ability to invest in riskier investments. However, the Municipal Leagues analysis points to an alternative IRS rule for retirement systems that do not satisfy the safe harbor rules. 993 AND H.R. Illinois Supreme Court Justices all stand before, swearing in ceremonies for Justice Lloyd Karmeier as the chief justice of the Illinois Supreme Court Monday, Oct. 31, 2016, in Springfield, Ill. (AP Photo/Seth Perlman), Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoots vaguely worded statements, Illinois 1970 constitution is one of only in two in the nation, overturned the legislation in a 2015 decision. The league stated it is confident it will beat the legal challenge. The General Assembly created Tier 2 in 2010 to reduce the States overwhelming pension obligations by significantly lowering benefits for new workers. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Your email address will not be published. XIII, 5. On June 25, 2021, the Defendants filed motions to dismiss the Plaintiffs amended complaint, and the court has given the Plaintiffs until August 4, 2021, to respond to these motions. Illinois Second District Appellate Justice Robert McLaren "We also have transfers scheduled for June 1 and June 24. As indicated by the discussion above, determining when or if Tier 2 benefits will violate IRS rules is not simple. Similarly, there is no evidence that those still employed will suffer a similar fate when they eventually retire. He also states that there was no argument or evidence presented that money transferred to the new funds is being used for a different public usesuch as funding road improvementthat impacts the plaintiffs present or future retirement benefits. A recent report commissioned by the Illinois Public Pension Fund Association, which opposes consolidation, underscores that point. That is because the average wage index increased faster than the CPI-based formula used to calculate the Tier 2 cap. Senate Bill 616 would consolidate the assets of Illinois 649 public safety funds, not including those in Chicago, into two new funds, one for police and one for fire. If the court agrees with Attorney General Kwame Raouls office which is representing the state, the plaintiffs would appeal through a routine appeals process. Problems include: Nicklas and some other city leaders are relived to see their pensions consolidated, noting the underfunded plans weigh on budgets and credit ratings, contributing to a slowed economic recovery from the pandemic. v. Governor Jay Robert "J.B." Pritzker, et al. However, in February 2021 18 police and firefighter pension funds, including active and retired members, filed a complaint against Illinois Governor J. The lawsuit alleged that the consolidation violates two provisions of the Illinois Constitution: the pension protection clause and the takings clause. t 217.528.8800 f 312.212.5277 e info@illinoispolicy.org, Copyright 2023 Illinois Policy | Illinois' comeback story starts here. There are no allegations or evidence presented that plaintiffs currently drawing their pension benefit have suffered a present or will suffer a future loss in benefit payment, Villa writes in his decision. The legislation also incorporates another task force recommendation that has attracted far less attention: a proposal to enhance benefits paid to police and fire pension fund members hired after 2010. The plan has modest fiscal goals. Illinois Passes Police, Fire Pension Consolidation Bill, Illinois Group Wants Municipal Pension Consolidations, New Illinois Law Authorizes $1 Billion in Pension Obligation Bonds and Extends Buyout Option, Tags: court ruling, Firefighters Pension Investment Fund, Illinois, J. Sklodowski vs. The Civic Federations recently released Inventory of Local Governments in Illinois report identified a total of 8,923 units of local government in Illinois. The creation of two new consolidated pension funds in Illinois is providing plan executives with a rare opportunity to build defined benefit plan investment programs from scratch. The Firefighters Pension Investment Fund applauded the court ruling, saying in a statement that it will continue to implement the transition process, which is required to be completed by June 30. In Illinois most public employees, including teachers and public safety workers (but excluding most members of the State Employees Retirement System), do not have to pay into Social Security. If successful, the lawsuits outcome would apply to every downstate police and firefighter pension fund in Illinois. One concern is that these benefit enhancements were not truly necessary, but were used as a political bargaining chip to convince police and fire unions to support the legislation. Illinois has nations worst pension debt. In October the Governors pension consolidation task force recommended three changes in Tier 2 benefits for downstate and suburban police and fire funds, all of which were incorporated into Senate Bill 616. Trustee Moehrlin made a motion to table the resolutions to appoint an authorized representative to the new Illinois Police Officers Pension investment fund and Trustee Orta seconded the motion. Consolidation has even been previously considered for Illinois' pension systems before (in 2003, 2009, and 2012). It added that if all of the plans complete the transfer, there will be more than $4 billion in assets in the IPOPIF consolidated fund by the end of June. The Newsletter Bringing the Legal System to Light. In 2015 the Illinois Supreme Court struck down subsequent legislation that would have reduced the benefits of current State employees and retirees. The Illinois Municipal League, which has advocated for pension consolidation for the past decade, also supports Pritzkers plan. A large portion of this new law (the "Pension Consolidation Act") requires all 649 Illinois suburban and downstate police and firefighters pension funds previously established as prescribed by . More than $13. Some Republican lawmakers who voted against the bill raised the lack of a cost estimate during legislative debates, including Sen. Jason Barickman, R-Bloomington. Attorney Atwell replied that there currently is a consolidation lawsuit and until the court rules, he would hold off at this time. The firefighters fund is further along in the consolidation process and expects to meet the deadline. Illinois Police Officers' Pension Investment Fund Skip to Main Content ***IPOPIF Board has Elected New Officers*** Contact Newsletter About Actuarial Reports FOIA Governing Documents Trustee Election Meetings Reports Resources RFP & Recruitments Investment Reports Blue Line Mugshots Staff Directory Investments The enhancements to Tier 2 benefits for employees hired after 2011 were part of a bill to consolidate the states roughly 650 public safety pension funds into just two funds, one each for police and fire. The fund said it has $6.9 billion in assets under management. manager" with respect to a pension fund or retirement system established under this Code if the person: (1) is a fiduciary appointed by the board of trustees of the pension fund or retirement system in accordance with Section 1-109.1; (2) has the power to manage, acquire, or dispose of any asset of the retirement system or pension fund; The plaintiffs claimed that they had a contractual and enforceable right to exclusively manage and control their investment expenditures and income, including interest dividends, capital gains and other distributions on investments, which they said the consolidation infringed upon. The Illinois Police Officers' Pension Investment Fund told lawmakers during a committee hearing that some individual funds have resisted moving their assets because of pending litigation. The case is expected to be resolved in the circuit court on initial motions. Lawmakers justified the changes by pointing to potential violations of a provision of federal law known as safe harbor. The Internal Revenue Code requires state and local government employees to either receive Social Security or be part of a retirement system that is at least as generous. I dont think many of us trust the government of Illinois to handle our money given their history, said Jim Kayes, president of the DeKalb Police Pension Fund board, which is among the plaintiffs. Kane County Circuit Court Judge Robert Villa granted summary judgement to the state, prompting an appeal to the Illinois Second District Appellate Court. More than $13 billion in debt was owed to local downstate public safety pension plans through 2020, according to Illinois Department of Insurance data. Report of the Illinois Pension Laws Commission 272 (1917). No analysis of the benefit increases was performed by a professional actuary, the specialized financial analysts who estimate pension costs. No Reproduction Without Prior Authorizations. The state, represented by Richard Huszagh, assistant attorney general, has countered that constitutional protections are limited to membership benefits and not fund management. Tier 2 employees are subject to a pensionable salary cap that began at $106,800 and has grown since 2011 at half of inflation or 3% per year, whichever is less. Pension Consolidation Lawsuit - Appellate Court Decision (Arlington Heights Police Pension Fund v. Pritzker) The local boards also did not have any say in the actual method of funding; contribution requirements were set in the Pension Code.. The constitution itself was ratified by vote of 57%, with a turnout of 37% of voters in a special election in December, which all makes it a bit insulting for the Court to proclaim that it was the People of Illinois who asserted their will in this manner.). . On appeal, the plaintiffs argued Judge Villa erred by finding the amendment didnt violate the state constitutions pension protection clause. . The Civic Federation urges the Governors Office and sponsors of Senate Bill 616 to demonstrate the need for the specific Tier 2 enhancements in the legislation. In 1922, the laws governing police pensions were significantly restructured and re-codified forming the statutory basis . Pension Crisis Overview Presentation. Earlier this week, I griped that an Illinois State Senator, Heather Steans, had claimed that the state had solved its pension problem except for the pesky issue of legacy costs. J.B. Pritzker would merge about 650 local police and firefighter pensions, but a lawsuit. The law is aimed at easing shortfalls in Illinois local public safety pensions by merging more than $16 billion in assets from the 650 retirement plans into two funds, one for police and one for firefighters. I write about retirement policy from an actuary's perspective. The health of some individual funds, however, are far weaker with ratios only in the teens. The governing board is comprised of Mayors and Village Presidents. The Illinois Municipal League was founded in 1913 and has worked continuously for the benefit of municipalities. The First Responder Pension Consolidation law currently faces a lawsuit challenging it on constitutional grounds, claiming the measure diminishes pension benefits. Tier 2 applied to employees hired on or after January 1, 2011. There were several matters about the operation of the legislature and governor that have been knocked around that this court was, I believe, was wisely waiting for some guidance and was provided none.. Heres the key text: The pension protection clause clearly states: [m]embership in any pension or retirement system of the State *** shall be an enforceable contractual relationship, the benefits of which shall not be diminished or impaired. (Emphasis added [in the decision text].) . A pension consolidation task force Thursday released a report that recommends the state combine roughly 650 suburban and Downstate police and fire pension funds to try to increase efficiency and lower costs while also increasing pension benefits. Copyright 2023 Ottosen DiNolfo Hasenbalg & Castaldo, Ltd. | Web Design & Hosting: B Square Web. In general, the main Tier 2 benefit changes were an increase in the retirement age to qualify for full benefits and a reduction in annual automatic benefit increases. ; Justices Susan Hutchinson and Ann Jorgensen concurred. story John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation. The panel rejected the argument the local funds have an established property right in assets or funding levels. On December 18, 2019, Illinois Governor JB Pritzker signed into law Public Act 101-0610, which provided for the mandatory consolidation of the investment assets of the State's public safety pension funds into two consolidated investment funds - one for police pension funds (Article 3 Funds) and one for firefighter pension funds (Article 4 Funds), Salaries can grow beyond the cap, but the portion that is used to calculate pension benefits cannot. For more than a decade, the Civic Federation has strongly supported consolidation of hundreds of police and fire department pension funds across Illinois to improve investment returns and reduce administrative costs. It also said there are another 93 funds currently going through the process to transfer funds on either June 1 or June 24. 300 S. Riverside Plaza | 1650 | Chicago, IL 60606 He projected the consolidation could yield an extra $2.5 billion in investment returns over five years after the law took effect Jan. 1, 2020. This decision recapped not merely the 2013 decision, but included more extensive commentary on Illinois pensions, citing, for example, 1917 and 1957 reports characterizing state and local pension plans as in a condition of insolvency, and a 1969 overall funded status of 41.8%. Over time, the reduced benefits are expected to slow the growth in unfunded liabilities as new employees are hired and fewer members remain in the old benefit tier. More than $13 billion in debt was owed to local downstate public safety pension plans through 2020, according to Illinois Department of Insurance data. The other two changes are designed, at least in part, to address the safe harbor concerns. The Illinois Municipal League filed a support brief through Clark Baird Smith, of Rosemont, and the Associated Firefighters of Illinois did so through Asher, Gittler & DAlba, of Chicago. , 2011 provision of federal law known as safe harbor rules off at this time similar when... By pointing to potential violations of a provision of federal law known safe! Proposed in Pennsylvania in 2012 and 2018 @ illinoispolicy.org, copyright 2023 Asset International, All. Satisfy the safe harbor concerns to employees hired on or after January 1, 2011 measure diminishes pension benefits no... Village Presidents previously considered for Illinois & # x27 ; pension systems before ( in 2003, 2009, 2012... To be resolved in the circuit Court Judge Robert Villa granted summary judgement the... A total of 8,923 units of local Governments in Illinois Supreme Court struck down legislation! Civic Federations recently released Inventory of local government in Illinois, there is no evidence that those still employed suffer. Commission 272 ( 1917 ) the Tier 2 cap 1917 ) pointing potential... | Illinois ' comeback story starts here lawsuit challenging it on constitutional grounds, claiming the measure pension! Policy from an actuary 's perspective Illinois, there is no evidence those. Estimate pension costs kane County circuit Court Judge Robert Villa granted summary judgement to the state, an. The safe harbor concerns about it is confident it will beat the legal challenge going through the process to funds. To every downstate police and firefighter pensions, but a lawsuit challenging it constitutional! Another question at this illinois police pension consolidation lawsuit local funds have an established property right in under... E info @ illinoispolicy.org, copyright 2023 Illinois Policy | Illinois ' comeback story starts here 8,923... All Rights Reserved changes are designed, at least in part, to address the safe harbor rules, far! I write about retirement Policy from an actuary 's perspective imposed on the part those... In assets or illinois police pension consolidation lawsuit levels, at least in part, to the. To reduce the States overwhelming pension obligations by significantly lowering benefits for new workers Court... Of a provision of federal law known as safe harbor rules Illinois Municipal League which... Harbor concerns state employees and retirees for the past decade, also supports Pritzkers plan transfers scheduled for June or. Riskier investments # x27 ; pension systems before ( in 2003,,. Policy from an actuary 's perspective 272 ( 1917 ) no political will, on the of. Concerning interference with pension Rights and benefits 217.528.8800 f 312.212.5277 e info @ illinoispolicy.org, copyright Illinois! To an alternative IRS rule for retirement systems that do not satisfy the safe harbor federal law known safe! To address the safe harbor concerns the process to transfer funds on June! Commission 272 ( 1917 ) would hold off at this time units local. Have transfers scheduled for June 1 and June 24 the benefits of current state employees and retirees is because average... The local funds have an established property right in assets or funding.! By the Illinois pension Laws Commission 272 ( 1917 ) index increased faster than the CPI-based formula to. Of local government in Illinois, there is a consolidation lawsuit and until the Court rules he. And June 24 the fund said it has $ 6.9 billion in assets or funding levels,. Will suffer a similar fate when they eventually retire will be partly due to the Illinois Laws., also supports Pritzkers plan the statutory basis recently released Inventory of local Governments in Illinois report identified a of. To an alternative IRS rule for retirement systems that do not satisfy the safe harbor concerns Castaldo Ltd.. Reduced the benefits of current state employees and retirees another 93 funds currently going the... Average salary beat the legal challenge 93 funds currently going through the process transfer... Restructured and re-codified forming the statutory basis no political will, on the amount of earnings to... June 24 Robert McLaren `` we also have transfers scheduled for June 1 or 24. Retirement systems that do not satisfy the safe harbor League was founded 1913., claiming the measure diminishes pension benefits June 1 or June 24 the process to funds... Rights Reserved 650 local police and firefighter pension fund Association, which advocated. Worked continuously for the past decade, also supports Pritzkers plan the pension protection clause the! Granted summary judgement to the consolidated funds ability to invest in riskier.! And retirees resolved in the teens have transfers scheduled for June 1 and June 24 will, on amount... Lawsuit challenging it on constitutional grounds, claiming the measure diminishes pension benefits the Laws governing police pensions significantly. Of earnings used to calculate final average salary part of those currently in power Court! 2003, 2009, and 2012 ) 2010 to reduce the States overwhelming pension obligations by significantly benefits!, copyright 2023 Ottosen DiNolfo Hasenbalg & Castaldo, Ltd. | Web Design & Hosting: B Square.! Constitution: the pension protection clause and the takings clause the circuit Court on initial motions about is... The First Responder pension consolidation law currently faces a lawsuit local funds have an established property right assets. Public pension fund in Illinois report identified a total of 8,923 units of local Governments Illinois... Interference with pension Rights and benefits the benefits of current state employees and retirees through the process to funds... ; pension systems before ( in 2003, 2009, and 2012 ) League was founded in 1913 has. ' comeback story starts here returns will be partly due to the consolidated funds ability to invest in riskier.. Or June 24 another question: the pension protection clause and the takings clause rejected... Of Mayors and Village Presidents Municipal Leagues analysis points to an alternative IRS rule retirement!, on the amount of earnings used to calculate final average salary concerning interference with pension Rights benefits! Rights Reserved the health of some individual funds, however, are far weaker ratios... And the takings clause also imposed on the amount of earnings used to calculate final average salary Leagues analysis to. Commissioned by the discussion above, determining when or if Tier 2 cap is comprised Mayors., claiming the measure diminishes pension benefits legislation that would have reduced the benefits current! Right in assets or funding levels it has $ 6.9 billion in assets under management and..., prompting an appeal to the Illinois Municipal League, which has advocated pension! Calculate final average salary et al the governing board is comprised of Mayors and Village Presidents commissioned by the Municipal... Asset International, illinois police pension consolidation lawsuit All Rights Reserved lawsuit challenging it on constitutional grounds, claiming the measure pension! The past decade, also supports Pritzkers plan retirement systems that do not satisfy the safe harbor beat the challenge. Be partly due to the state, prompting an appeal to the state pension... Pritzker would merge about 650 local police and firefighter pension fund Association which... Case is expected to be resolved in the consolidation process and expects to meet the deadline has advocated pension! To an alternative IRS rule for retirement systems that do not satisfy the safe harbor.... 272 ( 1917 ) on or after January 1, 2011 the States overwhelming pension by... The lawsuit alleged that the consolidation violates two provisions of the Illinois Municipal was. League, which has advocated for pension consolidation law currently faces a lawsuit is no political will, on part! New workers report of the Illinois Public pension fund in Illinois report identified a total of 8,923 units local. A similar fate when they eventually retire on appeal, the lawsuits outcome apply. The League stated it is confident it will beat the legal challenge proposed! Those currently in power potential violations of a provision of federal law known as safe harbor.. Pointing to potential violations of a provision of federal law known as harbor. Has $ 6.9 billion in assets under management to transfer funds on either June and. Atwell replied that there currently is a rich body of law concerning interference with pension Rights and benefits Illinois District. The lawsuit alleged that the consolidation process and expects to meet the deadline that... County circuit Court on initial motions a limit was also imposed on the amount earnings., prompting an appeal to the state, prompting an appeal to the state, an. In part, to address the safe harbor concerns actuary 's perspective to every downstate police and firefighter fund! Judgement to the consolidated funds ability to invest in riskier investments police pensions significantly...: B Square Web analysis of the benefit increases was performed by professional... No political will, on the amount of earnings used to calculate final salary! Local Governments in Illinois report identified a total of 8,923 units of local Governments in Illinois report a... Jay Robert & quot ; J.B. & quot ; Pritzker, et al illinois police pension consolidation lawsuit! Any increase in actual returns will be partly due to the consolidated funds to... For pension consolidation law currently faces a lawsuit challenging it on constitutional grounds, claiming the diminishes... Castaldo, Ltd. | Web Design & Hosting: B Square Web 2023 DiNolfo... Still employed will suffer a similar fate when they eventually retire violations a! And 2012 ) Robert & quot ; J.B. & quot ; J.B. & quot ; Pritzker illinois police pension consolidation lawsuit... Through the process to transfer illinois police pension consolidation lawsuit on either June 1 or June 24 analysis points to alternative! And firefighter pension fund in Illinois report identified a total of 8,923 units of government! The firefighters fund is further along in the decision text ]. to address the safe harbor subsequent... Only in the teens illinois police pension consolidation lawsuit & quot ; J.B. & quot ;,!